Options

Does anyone know where I can get the "magic" cigarette for Mr. Applegate to use in Damn Yankees?

Most novelty and joke stores have "fake" cigarettes - usually filled with some talc to create a puff, frequently sold in packs of 2-4. A google search will enable you to order in bulk online for a longer run.

Uhm, probably magic or joke stores, that's where I've seen them.

http://www.theatrefx.com/store/commerce.cgi?product=handheld_devices

It is the second to last product on this page.  Good Luck!